The National Gathering of the Support Network of Catholic Health Care Chaplains (SNCHC) took place in October 2017. The theme of the opening session was Healthcare Chaplaincy and Pastoral Ethics. Up to one hundred hospital chaplains from across the country attended. Such a group of experienced professionals – both lay and ordained – holds a deep well of wisdom. Therefore, to draw from this source, the attendees were asked to respond to a Text, a Story, and a Case-Study.